You vill comply!


The aqua sky’s cloudless and the chirps of the birds are carried by the gentle breeze.  I casually cycle past a man watering his front lawn, my skin and spirits feel pleasantly warm.  My yellow bike reflects my mood.

Me:  Perfect day for a ride!

Him:  Mmm.  It’d be even more perfect if you were wearing a helmet.

Ugh.  The sun’s gone behind a metaphoric grey cloud.


I cross the road to go for a walk in the park beside the creek.  A car drives past.


I spontaneously laugh.  It feels like a 5-year-old just called me “poo-face”.

Are there people out there who genuinely think jaywalking is a crime so severe that it needs to be policed by civilians?  Really?

Yes must be the answer, since three separate jaywalking vigilantes have reprimanded me in the past year.


I stand at a pedestrian crossing with six others.  There are no cars in sight, and we can see the road for miles.  I want to cross, but I know the rules here.  I can also do without the crime of “jaywalker” being yelled at me twice in a week.

No one moves.  We all stand still, dead still, waiting for the green robot man to tell us we can walk.  Minutes pass in silence, the vacant road glaring in front of us.   Finally the green robot man blinks on, instructing the humanoids who obediently step forward.


I open a small bottle of wine and cross the road to the creek.

“Excuse me”?


“Um, you know you’re not allowed to drink on the street”?

Sigh.  Of course you aren’t.

Bike helmets are compulsory in Australia, jaywalking is illegal (and the law is actively enforced), drinking in public is banned, and you cross the street when you’re told to cross the street.

Last year it was proposed that Melbourne becomes a smoke-free city.  No smoking in the entire CBD.  Prohibition in 2014.  Oh and voting’s also compulsory – not voting incurs a $74 fine.

This is a land of laws.

Compliance is everything.

It’s tiring, it’s absurd, and it’s a constant challenge to those who have lived anywhere else.  It’s not the snakes, or the spiders, or the bushfires, or the sharks that’ll get you in Australia.  It’s the rules, the laws, and the cultural mindset.

Like a stint in prison, you have to brace yourself to live here – and the final sentence in this note from one American to another about living in Australia reads like the end of a custodial sentence:   “Those of us from the American south know an unbridled, exceptional amount of freedom and (aside from missing our loved ones), the rules and general rigidity of Australia can seem oppressive.  It wasn’t until my Aussie hubby came here and experienced our freedoms, that he understood why I found it so difficult to adjust in Sydney.  Living in Australia was extremely challenging for me, and it was an experience that made me a stronger, more resilient person.” 

Australia’s refreshingly wide and open land contradicts the human oppression and indoctrination.  A friend who visited Australia last year sent me an email which captured how it’s strikingly restrictive to those who have spent years in more relaxed countries.

“I never thought of the UK as free until I visited Australia. Whenever people have asked about my trip, the dismaying nanny-state rigidity of Australian society is all I’ve been able to talk about.  I couldn’t believe the constant, on-going presumption that various public authorities know best!  The rules and ever-present rigidity of Australia is genuinely amazing.  I’ve never experienced anything like it in any other country”.

Of course, there’s a positive side to the compliance.  The rules mean that we have high quality standards, cleanliness, “good” behaviour and civic order.  These are good things … though they also describe Germany.  I guess it’s a matter of whether you consider the price of those things to be worth it.  I’m not sure I do. I’m okay with a few cycling fatalities if it means all of us can have the wind in our hair.  I’m okay with the occasional smell of smoke if it means we can have the freedom to make our own choices.  I’m okay with a few drunks in the street, if it means I can enjoy a cold glass of wine by the creek on a warm summer evening.  Hell, with any luck, I’ll get a little tipsy and be one of those drunks! (And yes, I realise the risks of drinking by a river.  Yawn).

18 months ago, I had a word approved by the urban dictionary; Convictistan.  It’s used by non-Australians (often New Zealanders) when referring to Australia.  I meant it as a nod to our convict history.  Perhaps it’s not history.  Perhaps we’re all currently inmates in an open prison.


In October last year Jeremy Clarkson wrote about Australia in “The Times” …

So I was in a helicopter.  The doors were off, I had a rifle and the pilot was hovering 100ft from the ground so I could shoot a wild pig.  Later we butchered it and over a few beers fed it to his pet crocodile.  This is the all-male, rough-and-tumble image we have of life in Australia.  But it’s wrong …

The following morning, all I wanted was a cigarette and a cup of coffee in the morning sunshine, but down under, this is no longer really possible.

I made the short 300-yard walk from the restaurant to what was billed as the smoking terrace. But a waiter sprinted over to say that the actual smoking terrace was even further away, in a cave by the bins.

And that, yes, he could bring me a coffee, but only in a paper cup.

This is because he’d have to walk past the swimming pool.  Never mind that it was completely fenced off, and accessible through a gate so complicated that only a child could possibly work the latch, there was a chance that he would trip over one of the signs advising visitors that it was 0.2 metres deep, that diving was banned, that no lifeguard was on duty and that the water may contain traces of diarrhoea.

I’m not sure there’s a county on earth where the global perception is as far removed from the reality as Australia.  We see it as a land of spiders and snakes, where you are born drunk and with an ability to barbecue yourself. But it’s not like that at all.

Today the unholy alliance of the nanny state and the trade union movement has created a culture of health and safety so all-consuming that no one is allowed to die, or even fall over. Cigarettes are sold in packets made from the diseased lungs of dead babies, drinking outside is not allowed and there are speed limits on roads where there is literally nothing to hit.  You could have a crash lasting two hours and you’d still be fine.

The last fatality from a spider bite was in 1979, and every single river in the outback is garnished with floats … Australia can keep its ludicrous attitude to health and safety …”

13 responses to “You vill comply!

  1. Oh No! Is this what I am destined for, a walled garden?

  2. Oh I’ve missed you! Please keep going!
    By the way this is very eye opening for me. I find the attitudes of Scottish people when we visit often very conservative and narrow minded (though this could just be the particular group I am exposed to) and there’s all these social ‘rules’ that I am supposed to adhere to. I guess I’ve just become used to a different set of rules here…

    • Thanks for the encouragement – I’ve missed posting them!

      The rules are different, yes, but the actual enforced laws are significantly higher in Australia. In England the historic laws exist, but are NEVER enforced – they’re just treated like the joke they are (“What? I can’t carry a duck while crossing a pavement on a rainy day?!”)

      On Monday a friend of mine was fined $74 for jaywalking in Melbourne. She didn’t even know that was “a thing“. And to quote her “I’m an adult woman and mother of two children and I can’t determine that it’s safe to cross the road?!”

      • Ah yes, very true. Within a month of moving back to Australia Calum was fined for parking his car facing the wrong way. He was flabbergasted that a) it was wrong and b) you could get significantly fined for it.

      • Don’t get me started. There’s no thought to the practical necessity of laws (as in, they’re mostly not practical or necessary but NO ONE questions them!). I can’t bear it.

        Even your wording of it facing the “wrong” way is part of the mindset that’s ingrained. It’s not the “wrong” way … it’s just opposite to the direction of the traffic on that side of the road and all of Europe (a LOT more people than Australia) have proven that there’s not the slightest danger in doing it. Australians are programmed to think of things as right or wrong (mostly wrong) when that’s not the case. (I know you didn’t mean anything by the word “wrong” by the way – I’m not having a go at you about it :))

        In other words it’s not wrong to be parked on the other side of the street, but it’s illegal. And the fact that it’s illegal IS wrong! 🙂

  3. Ha! You’re a funny girl! l love the humour and detailed descriptions that you use when you write. Good to see you getting back to ‘Simone Scribbles’.

    • I might be funny but I WISH I was joking about the suffocating laws this country has! Remember the times in our childhood where we peeled off layers of sunburn? Children today don’t even get to experience that small pleasure.

      There’s a law for everything and it takes away all the fun. A life lived in fear of what “might” happen is no life at all!

  4. “It’s tiring, it’s absurd, and it’s a constant challenge to those who have lived anywhere else. It’s not the snakes, or the spiders, or the bushfires, or the sharks that’ll get you in Australia. It’s the rules, the laws, and the cultural mindset.” It IS the snakes and sharks – you don’t fool me with your blogging lies.  Happy 2015 btw. 

  5. Great to see you back on the blogging. Will this be a feature of 2015? I hope so.

Leave a Reply to Simone Scribbles Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s